Defining and Coping with Wicked Problems: The Case of Fort Ord Building Removal

Abstract

Globalization and interdependencies have given rise to a new type of problem-some call them "wicked". Wicked problems are confounding experts in many disciplines of study. They are inherent to policy and strategic planning issues in civilian and military settings. The traditional, linear methods of problem solving are inadequate to address the complexity of wicked problems, and thus require new methods of problem solving. This thesis begins with a review of the definitions of wicked problems and strategies for coping with them. In order to demonstrate the utility of these concepts to a military audience, the building removal aspect of the Fort Ord base closure is utilized as an illustration of a wicked problem. The thesis first identifies the characteristics of a wicked problem in the Fort Ord case, and then proposes a strategy for coping with Fort Ord building removal. The Fort Ord example is not unique within the Department of Defense, and lessons learned from this illustration are applicable not only to other closed bases and to future rounds of base closure, but also to other issues marked by complexity and interdependence.

Open PDF

Document Details

Document Type
Technical Report
Publication Date
Mar 01, 2001
Accession Number
ADA391566

Entities

People

  • David S. Luckey
  • Kevin P. Schultz

Organizations

  • Naval Postgraduate School

Tags

Communities of Interest

  • Biomedical
  • Energy and Power Technologies
  • Human Systems

DTIC Thesaurus Topics

  • Air Force Facilities
  • Air Pollution
  • Base Closures
  • Business Administration
  • Commerce
  • Environment
  • Environmental Protection
  • Environmental Restoration And Remediation
  • Families (Human)
  • Governments
  • Health Services
  • Medical Personnel
  • National Security
  • Public Administration
  • Recreation
  • Waste Management
  • Water Resources

Readers

  • Applied Combinatorial Optimization and Logic Circuit Design.
  • Energy Conservation and Renewable Energy Engineering.
  • Systems Analysis and Design