Military Advice and Civil-Military Relations
Abstract
As the United States leads the world into the 21st Century, military leaders must gain and maintain the trust of the President and the Secretary of Defense by understanding and influencing the manifold variables that affect the civilian-military relationship. This monograph looks at two time frames during America's history -- the Vietnam War (1965-1968) and Operation Iraqi Freedom (2003-present) -- in which the American military perceived that civilian leaders ignored its advice. In both of these instances, for a myriad of reasons, the advice of the military was not heard or was marginalized by either the President, the Secretary of Defense, or both. There are several variables that influenced the relative deafness of the civilian leadership during these two times of war. Of concern here is the extent of military service that resides in the civilian leadership, military leaders' political expertise, and the environment of service parochialism. The author concludes that the lack military experience on the part of civilian leaders does not detract from the military security of the nation, the effects of military leaders' political expertise largely depends on the type of conflict the nation is engaged in, and service parochialism is a factor of civilian leaders' receptiveness to military advice. In the aggregate, politicians will only hear and listen to military leaders if several things manifest themselves simultaneously. First, regardless of the civilian leadership's experience in the military, the political administration must respect military culture. Second, military leaders must have political experience to understand the ancillary functions of irregular warfare. Finally, there must exist a service culture that is divided enough to offer different opinions and alternatives, but not so divisive that it appears ineffectual and incoherent.
Document Details
- Document Type
- Technical Report
- Publication Date
- May 01, 2010
- Accession Number
- ADA523125
Entities
People
- Douglas W. Bennett
Organizations
- United States Army Command and General Staff College